by mike dennis
A few years ago, I seriously considered getting out of pastoral ministry and finding another way to live. Fortunately, I have no marketable job skills so I had to stay with the only thing I knew. During that period I would walk by the greeters at Walmart and wonder if they were happy. I visited people in the hospital who had suffered heart attacks and felt envious. I’m not sure where the “bottom” is for me but I had to be close.
I always thought that these things only happened to “those guys”
I want to be honest here. I know that there are many pastors who are suffering alone and think that no one gets it or understands. I guess I’m writing for them, though I’m not sure that any of my colleagues will read this. I obviously can’t mention names, but here goes. Here is my story.
After being a pastor for decades, and serving God and people to the best of my limited ability, I found myself in a horrible situation. In my ministerial arrogance, I had always thought that these things only happened to “those guys” who didn’t know how to handle people. They probably did something stupid and it was coming back on them, you know, like “Christian karma”. 🙂
There is no way I can express what it was really like. I had served this particular congregation for several years and had reached a point where I knew that some deep changes needed to take place for the church to move forward. I wanted to make these necessary changes intentionally and methodically, prayerfully and carefully. The church was nearing 100 years old and was operating pretty much as it had for many years. Surprisingly, it was still fairly large, although several hundred less people attended than during their heyday.
I had met with all of the leaders personally and individually to get their feedback on the plan I sensed God was showing me, and they all seemed to be positive and favorable. We had gone through a building program and it had been quite successful. We had shown moderate growth over the previous years. I was personally leading a group of college-aged new converts in discipleship each week. Things seemed to be going pretty well. But it all blew up in my face.
The real issue was that there was a member who had been part of the church for years and wanted a payed position. For reasons I will not enumerate here, it was not something that would have been right for the future direction of the church. He was receiving a part-time salary but he wanted full time. As we made the necessary changes, I told him that he would not be continuing in his position. So, he worked behind the scenes to undermine everything that I was trying to accomplish. When I met with the board to get the final approval on the plan, the meeting erupted into accusations and arguments. I was absolutely blown away.
“I can still see one red-faced leader pointing at me and yelling, his feet still dripping”
Then the the phone calls started. People who I thought were my friends were accusing and blaming. Finally on a leadership weekend with the board I apologized for anything I had done to hurt anyone. I implored them that we go forward for the sake of Christ and the Kingdom. I then got on my knees and washed their feet. I began to weep over each person there. And when I had finished, still on my knees with swollen eyes in the middle of them all, they began to point at me and utter accusations. I was destroying their church. People were leaving and it was my fault. I was mistreating people. I can still see one red-faced leader pointing at me and yelling, his feet still dripping. I had never been so absolutely crushed and devastated in all my life.
I was done. That was it. There were a thousand other things that had gone on behind the scenes, and I was at my personal breaking point. I couldn’t sleep and was having nightmares. I would have fits of uncontrollable crying. I went to my doctor and he said I needed to take some time off. He wrote a letter to my church leadership. He prescribed medication normally used by people with PTSD. I took my leave with the blessing of one precious couple who encouraged us. They even paid for my wife and I to go for a week of counseling in Florida.
During those weeks some things became clear. I felt alone and helpless. Even staff members whom I had hired and loved didn’t call to see how I was doing. Out of a church of over 500, only two people called. I didn’t find any help from my superiors, either. In all of my ministry I never had anyone call a Superintendent to report me in a negative way. When I called him to speak about what was happening, he informed me that 8 different people from my church had called or visited him. Not once had he let me know about any of them until this phone call. It definitely seemed final. I thought I was finished, and that I might possibly be losing my mind.
For reasons I cannot explain, I began to get calls from other churches. One was a mega-church. The interview went well, but Debbie and I knew that it wasn’t right. Then we went to another church for an interview. I didn’t like the location and the building looked a little run-down and neglected. But during the interview, we felt an amazing love that we hadn’t sensed for a long time. We accepted their call to come and follow the Lord with them, and have been blessed to lead these wonderful, loving, serving people ever since.
Here are 5 observations I want to share from this experience.
- All people are broken, but some people are mean. I’ve encountered them all my ministry. I’ve even been one of them a time or two. Sometimes they don’t know they are being mean. They have most likely suffered cruelty in some way in their own lives. But that doesn’t change the fact that they can be vicious and uncaring. And the hurt is real. If you have a dog with a biting problem, I may not shoot your dog, but I am not going to pet him, either. Neither should we be expected to enable the hurtful behavior of the few who seem to be the most vocal and controlling.
- Hurt is inevitable, forgiveness is a choice. Everyone gets hurt, but forgiveness is a daily choice. I say daily because I’ve preached forgiveness like you just forgive, flip a switch, and move on. But when a hurt is deep, it will keep hurting even after you decide to forgive people for their part in it. So forgiveness is a choice we make, followed by a long battle we fight. The more we forgive, the less the pain. But there is no magic bullet.
- I didn’t do a lot of things right. In my desire to lead them I had not really loved them as I should have. It took me about two and a half years to finally admit that part of the problem was that I didn’t work hard enough at loving some of them. If I could do things over, I would have concentrated more on loving them. That’s on me.
- Some churches have a history of abusing their pastors. Call them dysfunctional, call them toxic, or any one of the other descriptives, the fact is that for whatever reason these churches see pastors as the fall guy when things don’t go well. In some cases I found people waiting to pounce on me for some insignificant foible or mistake. They honestly didn’t trust me from the very beginning. It was nothing I had done, but an existing mindset with several of the people there. I’ve been fortunate to pastor several congregations that were loving and supportive, and only two that were really crushing. And the sad truth is that the alligators are pretty few in number, but the good folks are too nice to confront them, creating the situation of a revolving door on the pastor’s study.
- Losers don’t always quit, but quitters always lose. My superiors told me that it would be better to go elsewhere, so God worked it out for us to move. But I didn’t quit the ministry, and I am glad! Quitting is all too common these days. I see young men and women set out in the ministry only to leave dejected after a year or two. I’ve seen some of my friends quit after many years, finally collapsing beneath the enormous burden of serving with little appreciation while being insufficiently compensated. At times, quitting is necessary due to health or even marital relationship reasons. But for me, hanging in there when everything inside me was screaming “run!” has revealed a side of Jesus I never would have discovered otherwise. He really is near to the broken hearted. He really does minister to the weary. He really does provide for our needs. He really never leaves us or forsakes us. He really is the friend that sticks to me closer than even one of my awesome brothers. He really does give strength to the weak.
Let me know if this has helped anyone. You can reach me here or at mdennis248@aol.com. I’d love to hear your story and how God is helping you now.
